HP EliteBook 840 G5 14" Vs Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13"

HP EliteBook 840 G5 14"
HP EliteBook 840 G5 14"
Starting at

Refurbished price:£234.00

Versus £499.00 new

See options
Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13"
Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13"
Starting at

Refurbished price:£215.00

Versus £598.29 new

See options

Ratings

The HP EliteBook 840 G5 14 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13 are distinct laptop models designed for different user priorities. Released in 2018, the EliteBook 840 G5 is a business-oriented notebook, while the Surface Laptop 3 13, launched in 2019, offers a more consumer-focused experience. The primary differentiators lie in their design philosophy, port selection, and target user base, with the EliteBook emphasizing robust security and connectivity for professionals, and the Surface Laptop prioritizing a sleek design and a high-resolution touchscreen for everyday use.

Scores

Durability

When considering the longevity of these devices, their release timelines and design philosophies play a significant role.

  • Release Timeline & OS Support: The HP EliteBook 840 G5 was released in February 2018, preceding the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13, which launched in October 2019. Both devices originally shipped with Windows 10 and are capable of upgrading to Windows 11, meaning they will continue to receive software updates for several years. The Surface Laptop 3, being newer, may receive official OS support for a slightly longer duration.
  • Build Quality & Repairability: The EliteBook 840 G5 features an aluminum unibody design and has undergone MIL-STD testing for durability against various environmental factors, suggesting a robust build for demanding environments. It also includes tethered screws, making internal access for service or upgrades more straightforward. The Surface Laptop 3 boasts a premium aluminum chassis, with some configurations offering an Alcantara material palm rest. Its SSD is designed to be removable by a skilled technician, indicating a degree of serviceability.
  • Expected Practical Lifespan: Both laptops are built with quality materials, suggesting a practical lifespan suitable for their intended use. The EliteBook's business-grade durability features may appeal to users requiring a device that can withstand more rigorous daily handling, while the Surface Laptop's premium construction offers a refined experience for general use.

Year of Release

2017

2019

OS

Windows 11

Windows 11

Performance

The performance capabilities of these laptops cater to different user needs, influenced by their internal components and design.

  • Processor Capabilities: The HP EliteBook 840 G5 is equipped with 8th-generation Intel Core processors, providing solid performance for multitasking and demanding business applications. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13 features 10th-generation Intel Core processors, offering improved speed and efficiency for everyday productivity, web browsing, and office tasks. While the Surface Laptop 3's newer generation processor provides a general boost, neither device is primarily designed for intensive tasks like professional-grade video editing or high-end gaming.
  • Storage and RAM: Both models offer various SSD storage options, contributing to fast boot times and responsive application loading. The EliteBook 840 G5 supports up to 32GB of RAM, allowing for extensive multitasking and handling of numerous applications simultaneously. The Surface Laptop 3 13 typically comes with up to 16GB of RAM, which is ample for most daily computing needs and moderate multitasking.
  • Battery Behavior: The EliteBook 840 G5 generally provides around 8 to 8.5 hours of battery life during typical web browsing, with some tests showing about 6.5 hours for video playback. The Surface Laptop 3 13 offers a longer battery life, often reaching around 9 hours and 17 minutes in web surfing tests, and up to 11.5 hours according to manufacturer claims, making it suitable for extended use away from a power outlet. Both support fast charging.

Memory (GB)

8 GB

8 GB

Processor

Core i5 - Gen 8 (U)

Core i5 - Gen 10 (G7)

Graphic card

Integrated Graphics

Integrated Graphics

Screen quality

The display experience on these two laptops presents notable differences in size, aspect ratio, and available features.

  • Display Technology and Resolution: The HP EliteBook 840 G5 features a 14-inch IPS display with a Full HD (1920x1080) resolution, providing clear visuals for productivity tasks. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13 comes with a 13.5-inch PixelSense touchscreen display, offering a higher resolution of 2256 x 1504 pixels. This results in a higher pixel density on the Surface Laptop 3, contributing to sharper text and images.
  • Aspect Ratio and Viewing Experience: The EliteBook 840 G5 typically uses a 16:9 aspect ratio, common for media consumption. The Surface Laptop 3 13, however, utilizes a 3:2 aspect ratio, which provides more vertical screen real estate, making it well-suited for document work, web browsing, and other productivity tasks that benefit from seeing more content without scrolling.
  • Brightness and Special Features: The EliteBook 840 G5's base model display can be dim, around 220 nits, but higher-end configurations offer significantly brighter panels, including options with HP Sure View privacy technology that can reach up to 700 nits. The Surface Laptop 3 13's display typically reaches around 348 nits, offering good brightness for indoor use and vivid colors with strong contrast.

Audiovisual

Both laptops include integrated cameras and audio systems designed for communication and media consumption, with some distinctions in their capabilities.

  • Camera System: The HP EliteBook 840 G5 includes a 720p IR webcam, which supports Windows Hello for facial recognition login. While functional for video calls, some reviews note the webcam quality can be blurry. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13 also features a 720p HD front-facing camera and a Windows Hello face authentication camera, providing clear visuals for video conferencing and secure login.
  • Microphone Quality: The EliteBook 840 G5 is equipped with three multi-array microphones, designed to capture clear audio for calls and recordings. The Surface Laptop 3 13 includes dual far-field Studio Mics, which are optimized for clear voice capture, particularly beneficial for online meetings and dictation.
  • Speaker Output: The EliteBook 840 G5 features Bang & Olufsen tuned stereo speakers, known for delivering good sound quality and a richer audio experience. The Surface Laptop 3 13 incorporates Omnisonic Speakers with Dolby Audio, with sound emanating through the keyboard. Users often praise these speakers for their surprising loudness, clarity, and bass response for a laptop.

Miscellaneous

Beyond core components, several practical elements differentiate these two laptops, impacting their usability and connectivity in various scenarios.

  • Connectivity Options: The HP EliteBook 840 G5 offers a comprehensive set of ports, including two USB 3.0 Type-A ports, a Thunderbolt 3 (USB-C) port, HDMI 1.4b, and an Ethernet port, catering to a wide range of peripherals and external displays. It also supports Wi-Fi 802.11ac and Bluetooth 4.2, with optional WWAN (4G LTE) for mobile connectivity. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13 provides a more streamlined selection with one USB-C (3.1 Gen 2 with Power Delivery), one USB-A, a 3.5mm headphone jack, and a Surface Connect port. It supports newer Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) and Bluetooth 5.0 standards. However, it lacks an HDMI port and Thunderbolt 3, which may necessitate adapters for certain setups.
  • Weight and Dimensions: The EliteBook 840 G5, with its 14-inch screen, weighs approximately 1.54 to 1.59 kg (3.4 to 3.5 lbs) and measures around 1.8 cm (0.7 inches) thick. The Surface Laptop 3 13, being a 13.5-inch device, is lighter, starting at about 1.25 kg (2.76 lbs) and is slightly thinner at 1.45 cm (0.57 inches). These differences impact portability, with the Surface Laptop 3 offering a more lightweight profile.
  • Security and Build Materials: The EliteBook 840 G5 emphasizes enterprise-grade security with features like a fingerprint reader, IR webcam for Windows Hello, SmartCard reader, and HP Sure Start for BIOS protection. Its aluminum chassis is designed for business durability. The Surface Laptop 3 also includes Windows Hello facial recognition and features a premium aluminum body, with some models offering an Alcantara fabric palm rest for a distinct tactile experience.

Weight

1480 g

3000 g

Screen size

14

13

User feedback for the HP EliteBook 840 G5 often praises its robust build quality, comprehensive security features, and comfortable keyboard, making it a reliable choice for business professionals. Criticisms sometimes point to the base model's display being dim and the overall design being less sleek compared to some consumer ultrabooks. Users appreciate its wide array of ports and the option for a privacy screen.

The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13 is frequently lauded for its elegant design, high-resolution PixelSense touchscreen with a productivity-friendly 3:2 aspect ratio, and excellent keyboard and trackpad. Its speakers also receive positive remarks for their quality. Common concerns include a more limited port selection, particularly the absence of an HDMI port and Thunderbolt 3, and its performance, while good for everyday tasks, may not satisfy users with more demanding workloads.

Users prioritizing extensive connectivity, robust security features, and a durable, business-grade build for a professional environment may find the HP EliteBook 840 G5 well-suited to their needs. Its larger screen and comprehensive port selection are beneficial for a traditional workstation setup. Conversely, users who value a sleek, lightweight design, a vibrant high-resolution touchscreen for content consumption and productivity, and a premium typing experience for everyday tasks will likely lean towards the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13. Its portability and modern aesthetic make it a strong contender for mobile users. Both devices offer quality-assured refurbished options, providing an eco-friendly alternative for those seeking reliable technology.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons