Dell Latitude 5420 14" Vs Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13"

Dell Latitude 5420 14"
Dell Latitude 5420 14"
Starting at

Refurbished price:£204.00

Versus £546.18 new

See options
Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13"
Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13"
Starting at

Refurbished price:£215.00

Versus £598.29 new

See options

Ratings

The Dell Latitude 5420, released in 2021, and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch, launched in late 2019, are both laptops designed for productivity and everyday use. While the Latitude 5420 emphasizes business-oriented features and upgradability, the Surface Laptop 3 focuses on a premium design and a high-resolution touchscreen experience. Both devices run on the Windows operating system, offering a familiar environment for many users.

Scores

Durability

When considering the long-term usability of these laptops, their release timelines and design philosophies play a significant role in their expected practical lifespan and software support.

  • Release Timeline: The Dell Latitude 5420, released in 2021, benefits from a more recent launch compared to the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch, which debuted in October 2019. This difference in age means the Latitude 5420 generally has a longer remaining period for official software and security updates.
  • Software Longevity: The Surface Laptop 3's official end of support from Microsoft was July 2024, meaning it no longer receives firmware and driver updates with security fixes or hardware improvements. While it can run Windows 11, the Latitude 5420, being newer, is expected to receive updates for a longer duration, offering extended software longevity and compatibility with future applications.
  • Repairability: The Dell Latitude 5420 is designed with repairability in mind, featuring accessible internal components and upgradable RAM and SSD storage. The Surface Laptop 3 received an iFixit repairability score of 5 out of 10, a notable improvement over its predecessors, with a removable SSD (though requiring a skilled technician) but a glued-down battery.

Year of Release

2020

2019

OS

Windows 11

Windows 11

Performance

The performance of these laptops is influenced by their internal components, with each offering a distinct experience for daily tasks and more demanding applications.

  • Processor Capabilities: The Dell Latitude 5420 features 11th Generation Intel processors, providing robust performance for business applications and multitasking. The Surface Laptop 3 13-inch is equipped with 10th Generation Intel processors, which offer good performance for web browsing, document creation, and media consumption, though it may show limitations with more intensive tasks like advanced photo or video editing.
  • Multitasking and Responsiveness: The Latitude 5420 typically comes with DDR4 RAM, often configurable up to 64GB across two slots, allowing for smooth multitasking and efficient handling of demanding workloads. The Surface Laptop 3 uses LPDDR4x RAM, with configurations up to 16GB or 32GB, which is generally efficient but is soldered, limiting future upgrades.
  • Storage Options: Both laptops utilize fast NVMe SSD storage, contributing to quick boot times and application loading. The Latitude 5420 offers a single M.2 NVMe slot, with options up to 1TB. The Surface Laptop 3 also offers SSD storage up to 1TB, with the SSD being removable by a skilled technician.
  • Battery Behavior: The Dell Latitude 5420, particularly with its 63Whr battery option, can deliver impressive battery life, with some configurations lasting through an entire workday and potentially into a second day with lighter use. The Surface Laptop 3 offers decent battery life, typically providing around 9 to 11 hours of use on a single charge, suitable for a full day of moderate activity.

Memory (GB)

8 GB

8 GB

Processor

Core i5-1145G7

Core i5 - Gen 10 (G7)

Graphic card

Intel Iris Xe Graphics

Integrated Graphics

Screen quality

The visual experience on these laptops differs significantly due to their display technologies and design choices.

  • Display Technology and Resolution: The Dell Latitude 5420 features a 14-inch IPS display, commonly in Full HD (1920 x 1080) resolution, with anti-glare properties suitable for various working environments. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch boasts a 13.5-inch PixelSense touchscreen display with a higher resolution of 2256 x 1504 pixels and a 3:2 aspect ratio, providing a sharper image and more vertical screen space for productivity tasks.
  • Brightness and Clarity: The Latitude 5420 offers various brightness options, with some higher-end panels reaching 400 nits and 100% sRGB coverage, enhancing outdoor usability and color accuracy. The Surface Laptop 3's display typically reaches around 348-400 nits of brightness, offering vivid colors and excellent contrast, making it enjoyable for media consumption and general use.
  • Refresh Rate and Viewing Experience: Both laptops generally feature a standard 60Hz refresh rate, which is suitable for everyday tasks and office work. The Surface Laptop 3's 3:2 aspect ratio provides a more expansive vertical viewing area, which can be beneficial for document editing and web browsing, while the Latitude 5420's 16:9 aspect ratio is more common for media consumption.

Audiovisual

Both laptops include integrated camera and audio systems designed for communication and media consumption, with some distinctions in their capabilities.

  • Camera System: The Dell Latitude 5420 is equipped with a 720p HD webcam, often featuring a privacy shutter and IR facial recognition for secure logins. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 also includes a 720p HD front-facing camera, which supports Windows Hello for facial authentication. While both are adequate for video calls, neither offers a Full HD camera for higher-resolution video conferencing.
  • Microphone Quality: The Latitude 5420 typically features dual-array microphones, designed to capture clear audio for calls and recordings. The Surface Laptop 3 also incorporates dual far-field Studio Mics, which are effective at picking up voices from a distance and reducing background noise during calls.
  • Speaker Output: The Dell Latitude 5420 includes speakers that are generally suitable for business use, though some user feedback suggests they could be improved for media consumption. The Surface Laptop 3 features Omnisonic Speakers with Dolby Audio, which are noted for delivering surprisingly loud and clear sound for a laptop, enhancing the media consumption experience.

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements differentiate these two laptops in terms of connectivity, design, and user convenience.

  • Connectivity Options: The Dell Latitude 5420 offers extensive connectivity, including two Thunderbolt 4 ports (USB-C), two USB-A 3.2 Gen 1 ports, HDMI 2.0, an RJ-45 Ethernet port, a microSD card reader, and optional Smart Card and microSIM slots for LTE connectivity. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch provides a more streamlined selection with one USB-A port, one USB-C port (not Thunderbolt 3), a 3.5mm headphone jack, and a Surface Connect port for charging and docking.
  • Weight and Dimensions: The Latitude 5420 starts from approximately 1.37 kg (3.03 lbs), making it a portable option for business users. The Surface Laptop 3 13-inch is slightly lighter at around 1.27 kg (2.79 lbs), contributing to its ultraportable design.
  • Build Materials and Durability: The Dell Latitude 5420 features a carbon fiber and magnesium reinforced chassis, known for its robust and solid feel, designed to withstand the rigors of business travel. The Surface Laptop 3 offers a premium all-metal aluminum chassis or an option with an Alcantara fabric keyboard deck, providing an elegant and refined aesthetic.
  • Security Features: The Latitude 5420 includes a webcam privacy shutter, IR facial recognition, and an optional fingerprint reader, alongside enterprise-level security features. The Surface Laptop 3 also offers Windows Hello facial authentication for secure and convenient logins.

Weight

3000 g

3000 g

Screen size

14

13

The Dell Latitude 5420 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch cater to different user priorities, reflecting their distinct design philosophies and target audiences.

Users often praise the Dell Latitude 5420 for its robust build quality, extensive port selection, and excellent battery life, making it a reliable workhorse for professionals who need diverse connectivity and long unplugged usage. Its upgradable RAM and storage are also frequently highlighted as significant advantages for long-term use and customization. Criticisms sometimes point to its more utilitarian design and, in some configurations, less vibrant display options compared to consumer-focused laptops.

The Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch is frequently lauded for its elegant, premium design, sharp PixelSense touchscreen display, and comfortable keyboard, offering a refined user experience. Its portability and Windows Hello facial recognition are also popular features. However, common concerns include its limited port selection (lacking Thunderbolt 3), the 720p webcam, and its performance being more suited for everyday tasks rather than demanding creative work or heavy gaming. The earlier end-of-life support for the Surface Laptop 3 is also a consideration for users prioritizing long-term official updates.

Users prioritizing a highly portable device with a premium aesthetic, a high-resolution touchscreen, and a focus on a streamlined experience may find the Microsoft Surface Laptop 3 13-inch well-suited to their needs. Conversely, individuals who require extensive connectivity, strong durability, upgradability, and extended battery life for business or demanding productivity tasks will likely lean towards the Dell Latitude 5420. Both models, when acquired as a quality-assured refurbished option, can provide a sustainable choice for different user profiles.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons