iPhone 12 Pro Max Vs iPhone 15 Plus

iPhone 12 Pro Max
iPhone 12 Pro Max
Starting at

Refurbished price:£236.00

Versus £979.00 new

See options
iPhone 15 Plus
iPhone 15 Plus
Starting at

Refurbished price:£344.00

Versus £799.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 12 Pro Max, released in 2020, and the iPhone 15 Plus, launched in 2023, both cater to users who prefer a larger smartphone experience with expansive displays. While the 12 Pro Max was the pinnacle of its generation, offering professional-grade features and a heavy-duty build, the 15 Plus brings modern refinements and updated hardware to a more streamlined and lightweight design. Both devices run the latest versions of iOS, though they differ significantly in their physical connectors, display interactions, and internal efficiencies. This comparison explores how these two large-format devices handle daily tasks and long-term use.

Scores

Durability

The three-year gap between these models significantly impacts their expected lifespan and software support, with the newer model offering a longer future window for updates.

  • Software Longevity: The iPhone 15 Plus is expected to receive iOS updates for several years beyond the iPhone 12 Pro Max, making it a more suitable choice for those who plan to keep their device for half a decade or more.
  • Physical Resilience: The iPhone 12 Pro Max features a stainless steel frame which is highly resistant to dents, whereas the iPhone 15 Plus uses a lighter aluminium frame. However, the 15 Plus benefits from an updated internal architecture that makes the back glass easier to replace if damaged.
  • Maintenance and Repair: Both devices are designed with high standards of water and dust resistance, but the newer internal layout of the 15 Plus reflects a shift towards better repairability for common components like the battery and screen.

Year of Release

2020

2023

Compatible with latest Update

Yes

Yes

OS

iOS

iOS

Foldable

No

No

Performance

In everyday use, both smartphones provide a smooth and responsive experience, though the newer hardware in the iPhone 15 Plus offers noticeable advantages in efficiency and sustained tasks.

  • System Responsiveness: The iPhone 15 Plus handles demanding applications and intensive multitasking with greater ease due to its more modern internal architecture, which stays cooler under load compared to the older model.
  • Battery Endurance: One of the most significant differences is battery performance; the iPhone 15 Plus is designed for exceptional longevity, often lasting well through a second day of moderate use, whereas the 12 Pro Max typically requires daily charging.
  • Memory Management: While both devices manage background apps effectively, the 15 Plus benefits from more efficient data processing, ensuring that switching between high-resolution video editing and social media remains fluid and lag-free.

Memory (GB)

6 GB

6 GB

Screen quality

Both devices feature expansive 6.7-inch displays, but the technology behind them has evolved to offer better visibility and a different way of interacting with notifications.

  • Outdoor Visibility: The iPhone 15 Plus features a significantly brighter display that remains clear even under direct sunlight, whereas the iPhone 12 Pro Max may be harder to read in very bright outdoor environments.
  • Interface Interaction: The 15 Plus introduces the Dynamic Island, a versatile area at the top of the screen that changes shape to show alerts and live activities, replacing the traditional static notch found on the 12 Pro Max.
  • Visual Clarity: Both screens use OLED technology to provide deep blacks and vibrant colours, making them excellent for watching high-definition films or editing photos with high colour accuracy.

Resolution

1284 x 2778

1290 x 2796

Screen type

Super Retina XDR OLED

Super Retina XDR OLED

Audiovisual

The camera systems represent two different philosophies: the 12 Pro Max focuses on versatile hardware with three lenses, while the 15 Plus uses high-resolution sensors and advanced software processing.

  • Photography Versatility: The iPhone 12 Pro Max includes a dedicated telephoto lens for optical zoom and a LiDAR scanner for faster focusing in dark environments, which is particularly useful for portrait photography.
  • Image Detail: The iPhone 15 Plus features a high-resolution main sensor that captures significantly more detail in standard shots and uses a clever cropping method to provide a high-quality zoom without a dedicated third lens.
  • Video and Audio: The 15 Plus offers improved video stabilisation modes that smooth out shaky handheld footage, while both devices feature high-quality microphones and stereo speakers that provide a clear, immersive audio experience for media.

Main camera

12 megapixels

48 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond the core specifications, the physical design and connectivity options mark a clear transition between two eras of smartphone technology.

  • Connectivity and Ports: The most notable change is the transition from the Lightning port on the 12 Pro Max to the universal USB-C port on the 15 Plus, which simplifies charging with cables used for laptops and other modern electronics.
  • Weight and Handling: Despite having the same screen size, the iPhone 15 Plus is noticeably lighter than the 12 Pro Max, making it more comfortable to hold for long periods or during one-handed use.
  • Biometric Security: Both devices utilise secure facial recognition for unlocking and payments, providing a seamless and fast experience that remains consistent across both generations of hardware.

Weight

226 g

201 g

Screen size (in)

6.7

6.7

Mobile network

5G

5G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

Connector

Lightning

USB-C

User consensus from various tech communities highlights that the iPhone 12 Pro Max is still highly regarded for its premium stainless steel feel and the inclusion of a dedicated zoom lens. However, some users note that its weight can be tiring over time. Conversely, the iPhone 15 Plus receives significant praise for its exceptional battery life and the convenience of the USB-C port, though some long-term users miss the dedicated telephoto camera for distant subjects.

Users who prioritise a premium build and need a dedicated zoom lens for photography may find the iPhone 12 Pro Max better suited to their needs. On the other hand, those who value a lighter device, the longest possible battery life, and the latest charging standards will likely prefer the iPhone 15 Plus. Choosing a quality-assured refurbished option allows users to access these advanced features while supporting a more circular economy. Ultimately, both smartphones offer a high-quality, large-screen experience, and opting for a sustainable choice like a refurbished device ensures that high-performance technology remains in use for longer. The decision rests on whether one values the professional features of an older flagship or the modern efficiencies of a newer model.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons