Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra (14.6", 2023) Vs iPad Air 5 (2022, M1 series)

Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra (14.6", 2023)
Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra (14.6", 2023)
Starting at

Refurbished price:£493.00

Versus £1,364.76 new

See options
iPad Air 5 (2022, M1 series)
iPad Air 5 (2022, M1 series)
Starting at

Refurbished price:£274.00

Versus £669.00 new

See options

Ratings

The Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra, released in August 2023, and the Apple iPad Air (M1 series), launched in March 2022, represent distinct approaches to the tablet experience. While both are powerful devices designed for productivity and entertainment, they differ significantly in their operating systems, screen sizes, and overall design philosophy. The Tab S9 Ultra runs on Android with Samsung's One UI, offering a large, expansive display, whereas the iPad Air operates on iPadOS, providing a more compact form factor with a focus on Apple's ecosystem.

Scores

Durability

When considering the longevity of these tablets, several factors come into play, including their release timelines, software support, and physical durability.

  • Release Timeline: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra was released in August 2023, making it a newer device compared to the iPad Air (M1 series), which launched in March 2022. This difference in release date means the Tab S9 Ultra will likely receive software updates for a longer period.
  • Software Longevity: Samsung typically provides several years of Android and security updates for its flagship tablets, while Apple is known for its extended software support for iPadOS, often spanning 5-6 years or more from the device's release. Users prioritizing the absolute longest software support might find the iPad Air's established track record appealing, though the Tab S9 Ultra, being newer, will have its support window extend further into the future.
  • Durability Features: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra boasts an IP68 rating for water and dust resistance, offering a higher level of protection against environmental elements. Both devices feature robust build materials, with the Tab S9 Ultra incorporating Corning Gorilla Glass for screen protection. Repairability for the Tab S9 Ultra is considered moderate, with accessible battery components but delicate screen removal processes.

Year of Release

2023

2022

Compatible with latest Update

Yes

Yes

OS

Android

iPadOS

Performance

Both tablets offer robust performance capabilities, designed to handle a wide range of tasks from everyday browsing to more demanding applications, though they achieve this through different hardware and software optimizations.

  • Processing Power: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra provides smooth performance for demanding applications, multitasking, and graphics-intensive games, maintaining responsiveness without significant slowdowns. The iPad Air (M1 series) also delivers snappy performance, capable of running multiple apps simultaneously, handling video editing, and graphic design tasks efficiently, comparable to some professional-grade devices.
  • Storage and Multitasking: The Tab S9 Ultra offers a wider range of storage options, from 128GB up to 1TB, and includes a microSD card slot for expandable storage, providing flexibility for users with large media libraries or extensive project files. It also comes with varying RAM configurations (8GB, 12GB, 16GB) to support intensive multitasking. The iPad Air is available with 64GB or 256GB of internal storage, which may be a limiting factor for users requiring extensive local storage, and typically features 8GB of RAM.
  • Battery Behavior: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra is equipped with a large 11,200 mAh battery, often providing all-day usage with regular tasks and up to 11 hours of screen-on time for lighter use. The iPad Air (M1 series) generally offers up to 10 hours of web surfing or video playback on a single charge, though real-world battery life can vary, with some users reporting faster drain during heavy use or at high brightness settings.

Memory (GB)

12 GB

8 GB

Screen quality

The visual experience on both tablets is a key differentiator, with each offering distinct display technologies and characteristics that cater to different user preferences.

  • Display Technology and Size: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra features a large 14.6-inch Dynamic AMOLED 2X display, known for its deep blacks, vibrant colors, and high contrast, making it well-suited for media consumption and creative work. The iPad Air (M1 series) has a more compact 10.9-inch Liquid Retina IPS LCD display, which provides accurate colors and wide viewing angles.
  • Resolution and Clarity: The Tab S9 Ultra offers a resolution of 2960 x 1848 pixels, resulting in sharp images and text across its expansive screen. The iPad Air features a 2360 x 1640 pixel resolution, delivering clear visuals on its smaller display.
  • Brightness and Smoothness: With a peak brightness of 930 nits, the Tab S9 Ultra's display is bright enough for comfortable indoor use and improved visibility outdoors. It also features a 120Hz adaptive refresh rate, providing smooth scrolling and a fluid user interface. The iPad Air has a standard 60Hz refresh rate, which offers a consistent viewing experience, and its brightness is suitable for most indoor environments.

Resolution

1848 x 2960

2360 x 1640

Screen type

Dynamic AMOLED 2X

Liquid Retina display

Pixel density

240ppp

264ppp

Audiovisual

While tablets are not typically primary photography devices, both the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra and iPad Air offer capable camera systems for video calls, document scanning, and casual photography.

  • Rear Camera System: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra is equipped with a dual rear camera setup, including a 13MP main lens and an 8MP ultra-wide lens. These cameras are suitable for capturing documents and everyday photos in good lighting conditions. The iPad Air features a single 12MP wide rear camera, which performs adequately for general photography and augmented reality applications.
  • Front Camera and Video Conferencing: For video calls, the Tab S9 Ultra includes dual 12MP front-facing cameras (wide and ultra-wide), providing clear images and audio. The iPad Air also excels in video conferencing with its 12MP ultra-wide front camera, which supports Apple's Center Stage feature, keeping the user in frame during calls.
  • Audio Experience: The Tab S9 Ultra features a quad-speaker system, delivering a rich audio experience for media consumption and gaming. The iPad Air comes with a stereo speaker system, offering clear sound for videos and music.

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience and differentiate these two tablets.

  • Connectivity and Ports: The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra supports Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3, with optional 5G connectivity, and features a USB-C 3.2 port. The iPad Air (M1 series) includes Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth 5.0, also with optional 5G on cellular models, and a USB-C port.
  • Input and Biometrics: The Tab S9 Ultra comes with an S Pen stylus included, offering a natural writing and drawing experience, and features an in-screen fingerprint sensor. The iPad Air supports the second-generation Apple Pencil (sold separately) and incorporates Touch ID into its power button for secure authentication.
  • Dimensions and Handling: The Tab S9 Ultra is a larger and heavier device, measuring 326.4 x 208.6 x 5.5 mm and weighing 732g (Wi-Fi model), which can make it less portable but provides a vast screen for productivity. The iPad Air is more compact and lighter at 247.6 x 178.5 x 6.1 mm and 461g (Wi-Fi model), making it easier to handle and carry.

Weight

129 g

461 g

Screen size (in)

14.6

10.9

Network

Wi-Fi + 5G

Wi-Fi

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Without SIM Port

User feedback for the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra often highlights its expansive and vibrant AMOLED display as a major draw, making it ideal for immersive media consumption and detailed creative work. Users also praise its powerful performance for demanding tasks and the versatility offered by DeX mode, which provides a desktop-like experience. The included S Pen and IP68 water resistance are frequently cited as significant advantages. Some common criticisms revolve around its large size, which, while beneficial for screen real estate, can make it less convenient for handheld use or portability.

For the iPad Air (M1 series), users consistently commend its strong performance, attributing it to the efficient processor that handles multitasking and intensive applications with ease. Its integration within the Apple ecosystem and compatibility with accessories like the Apple Pencil and Magic Keyboard are also highly valued. Criticisms sometimes point to the base storage option being limited and the display lacking the higher refresh rate or OLED technology found in more premium tablets. Some users also report that battery life can be significantly impacted by high brightness settings or very heavy usage.

Users prioritizing a large, high-contrast display for entertainment, drawing, or a desktop-like Android experience with expandable storage may find the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra well-suited to their needs. Conversely, individuals seeking a more compact, highly performant tablet within the Apple ecosystem, with a strong track record of software support, might lean toward the iPad Air (M1 series). Both devices offer compelling features for different user profiles, and considering a quality-assured refurbished option for either can be an eco-friendly alternative.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons