Dell Latitude 5420 14" Vs Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15"

Dell Latitude 5420 14"
Dell Latitude 5420 14"
Starting at

Refurbished price:£199.00

Versus £546.18 new

See options
Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15"
Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15"
Starting at

Refurbished price:£1,499.00

Versus £2,000.00 new

See options

Ratings

The Dell Latitude 5420 14 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15 are both designed for productivity, offering distinct approaches to performance, portability, and user experience. Released in 2021, the Dell Latitude 5420 is a business-oriented laptop, while the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5, launched in 2022, presents a more refined consumer-focused design. Both devices operate on the Windows platform, but they cater to different priorities in terms of display, connectivity, and internal architecture.

Scores

Durability

When considering the longevity of a laptop, factors such as release date, operating system support, and repairability play a significant role. The Dell Latitude 5420 was released in early 2021, while the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 followed in late 2022, giving the Surface Laptop 5 a slight advantage in terms of newer components and potentially longer software support from its release date.

  • Software Support: The Surface Laptop 5, being a newer model, is expected to receive operating system updates for a longer duration compared to the Latitude 5420, ensuring extended compatibility with future software and security enhancements. Both run on Windows, with the Latitude 5420 typically shipping with Windows 10 Pro or 11 Pro, and the Surface Laptop 5 with Windows 11 Home or Pro.
  • Repairability and Upgradability: The Dell Latitude 5420 offers upgradable RAM and storage through its SODIMM slots and M.2 NVMe SSD slot, allowing users to extend its practical lifespan by enhancing components. In contrast, the Surface Laptop 5's RAM is soldered, making it non-upgradable, though its SSD is removable in some configurations, particularly the commercial versions, which can aid in servicing.
  • Physical Durability: The Latitude 5420 features a chassis constructed with carbon fiber and magnesium reinforcement, designed for business environments where durability is a key concern. The Surface Laptop 5 boasts an aluminum chassis, offering a sleek and premium feel, with Gorilla Glass 5 protecting its display.

Year of Release

2020

2022

OS

Windows 11

Windows 11

Performance

The performance of these laptops is influenced by their respective processor generations, RAM configurations, and storage solutions, impacting how smoothly they handle daily tasks and more demanding applications.

  • Processor Capabilities: The Dell Latitude 5420 is equipped with 11th Generation Intel Core processors, which provide solid performance for typical business applications, multitasking, and general productivity. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 features 12th Generation Intel Core processors, offering improved efficiency and performance for snappy multitasking across various applications and tabs.
  • Memory and Storage: The Latitude 5420 supports DDR4 RAM, configurable from 4GB up to 64GB across two SODIMM slots, providing flexibility for users who require significant memory for intensive workloads or prefer future upgrades. The Surface Laptop 5 utilizes faster LPDDR5x RAM, available in 8GB, 16GB, or 32GB configurations, which is soldered to the motherboard. Both laptops feature fast M.2 PCIe NVMe SSDs for quick boot times and application loading, with storage options ranging from 256GB to 1TB.
  • Battery Behavior: The Latitude 5420 typically offers a 42 Whr or 63 Whr battery, providing around 7 to 9 hours of real-world usage for common tasks, and supports ExpressCharge for rapid recharging. The Surface Laptop 5, with a 47.4 Wh battery, generally delivers 9 to 10 hours of web browsing or 7 to 8 hours of video playback in real-world tests, despite Microsoft's higher claims.

Memory (GB)

8 GB

16 GB

Processor

Core i5-1145G7

Core i7-1255U

Graphic card

Intel Iris Xe Graphics

Integrated Graphics

Screen quality

The visual experience on these laptops differs significantly due to variations in display technology, resolution, and aspect ratio, catering to different user preferences for clarity and screen real estate.

  • Display Technology and Resolution: The Dell Latitude 5420 features a 14-inch IPS panel, with common configurations offering Full HD (1920x1080) resolution and an anti-glare coating, which is beneficial for reducing reflections in bright environments. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15-inch model boasts a PixelSense touchscreen display with a higher resolution of 2496 x 1664 pixels, providing a sharper and more detailed image.
  • Brightness and Color: The Latitude 5420's display typically offers brightness levels between 250 and 300 nits, with some configurations reaching 400 nits and covering up to 100% sRGB, though base models might have lower color accuracy. The Surface Laptop 5's display is brighter, averaging around 400 nits and covering approximately 89% of the sRGB color gamut, making colors appear vibrant.
  • Aspect Ratio and Touch: The Latitude 5420 uses a traditional 16:9 aspect ratio, suitable for widescreen content. The Surface Laptop 5 features a 3:2 aspect ratio, which offers more vertical screen space, making it advantageous for document work, web browsing, and multitasking. The Surface Laptop 5 also includes a 10-point multi-touch PixelSense display, enhancing interactive capabilities.

Resolution

1920 x 1080

2256 x 1504

Screen type

LCD

LCD

Audiovisual

For communication and media consumption, the camera, microphone, and speaker quality are important considerations, and these two laptops offer different experiences in these areas.

  • Webcam Quality: The Dell Latitude 5420 often includes a Full HD IR webcam with a privacy shutter, providing clear video for virtual meetings and enhanced security through facial recognition. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 features a 720p HD front-facing camera, which is adequate for standard video calls but may not offer the same level of detail as a Full HD camera.
  • Audio Input: Both laptops are equipped with features to enhance audio input. The Latitude 5420 includes high-performing microphones for clear voice capture. The Surface Laptop 5 utilizes dual far-field Studio Mics, designed to pick up voices clearly even from a distance and reduce background noise.
  • Speaker Output: For media consumption and conference calls, the Latitude 5420 comes with standard stereo speakers. The Surface Laptop 5 features Omnisonic Speakers with Dolby Atmos, which aim to deliver a more immersive and richer audio experience.

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, practical elements like connectivity, physical design, and security features contribute to the overall user experience of these laptops.

  • Connectivity Options: The Dell Latitude 5420 offers a comprehensive array of ports, including two Thunderbolt 4 USB-C ports, two USB-A 3.2 Gen 1 ports, an HDMI 2.0 port, an RJ-45 Ethernet port, a universal audio jack, and a microSD card reader, providing extensive options for peripherals and networking. The Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 provides one USB-C port with Thunderbolt 4.0, one USB-A port, a 3.5mm headphone jack, and a Surface Connect port for charging and docking. Both support Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth 5.1 or 5.2 for wireless connectivity.
  • Weight and Dimensions: The Latitude 5420, with a 14-inch screen, starts from approximately 1.37 kg (3.03 lbs) and has dimensions of 321.35 x 212.1 x 19.3 mm. The 15-inch Surface Laptop 5 weighs around 1.56 kg (3.4 lbs) and measures 340 x 244 x 14.7 mm, making it slightly heavier but thinner than the Dell.
  • Security and Build Materials: The Latitude 5420 includes security features like an optional fingerprint reader, IR facial recognition, and a webcam privacy shutter, along with a robust chassis. The Surface Laptop 5 also features Windows Hello facial authentication and a sleek aluminum build.

Weight

3000 g

1296 g

Screen size

14

15

The Dell Latitude 5420 14 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 15 cater to users with differing priorities, as reflected in their design and feature sets. User feedback for the Latitude 5420 often praises its robust build quality, extensive port selection, and upgradable components, making it a practical choice for business and IT professionals who value longevity and flexibility. Some users, however, note that its display, while functional, may not be as vibrant or high-resolution as more modern consumer laptops, and its design is more utilitarian than sleek.

Conversely, the Surface Laptop 5 is frequently lauded for its premium design, high-resolution touchscreen display with a productivity-friendly 3:2 aspect ratio, and immersive audio experience. Users appreciate its portability and refined aesthetics. Common criticisms sometimes point to its limited port selection compared to some competitors, and the fact that its RAM is soldered, which restricts future upgrades. While its battery life is generally good, some real-world tests fall short of Microsoft's stated figures.

Users prioritizing a highly customizable and repairable laptop with a wide range of connectivity options, particularly for a professional or educational environment requiring wired network access and multiple peripherals, may find the Dell Latitude 5420 better suited to their needs. Its upgradable RAM and storage offer a pathway to extend its useful life. On the other hand, users who value a sleek, modern design, a high-quality touchscreen display for content consumption and creative tasks, and a more streamlined port selection with Thunderbolt 4 capabilities might lean towards the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5. Its 3:2 aspect ratio is particularly beneficial for document-centric work.

Both laptops represent solid choices within their respective categories. For those considering an eco-friendly alternative, quality-assured refurbished options for both the Dell Latitude 5420 and the Microsoft Surface Laptop 5 are available, providing a sustainable choice without compromising on performance or reliability.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons