iPhone 11 Pro Max Vs iPhone 12 Pro Max

iPhone 11 Pro Max
iPhone 11 Pro Max
Starting at

£191.00

£749.00 new

See options
iPhone 12 Pro Max
iPhone 12 Pro Max
Starting at

£232.00

£1,079.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 11 Pro Max, released in 2019, and the iPhone 12 Pro Max, arriving in 2020, represent two significant milestones in the evolution of Apple's large-format smartphones. While both devices share the "Pro Max" designation, signifying the most advanced features and largest screens available in their respective years, they offer distinct experiences in terms of physical design, connectivity, and internal capabilities. The iPhone 11 Pro Max is the final flagship of the rounded-edge era, while the iPhone 12 Pro Max introduced the flat-edged aesthetic that has defined subsequent generations.

Both smartphones operate on the iOS platform, ensuring a consistent user interface and access to a vast ecosystem of applications. However, the one-year age gap between them introduces differences in long-term software support and hardware efficiency. This comparison explores the practical differences between these two devices to help users determine which model best aligns with their daily needs and long-term expectations.

Scores

Durability

When evaluating the longevity of these two devices, the primary considerations are the release timeline and the durability of the materials used in their construction.

  • Software Support Timeline: The iPhone 12 Pro Max was released one year after the iPhone 11 Pro Max, which typically translates to an additional year of official software updates. While both devices currently support the latest versions of iOS, users who intend to keep their device for five years or more may find the newer model provides a longer window of security updates and new features.
  • Physical Durability: The iPhone 12 Pro Max introduced a front cover material known as Ceramic Shield, which offers significantly improved drop performance compared to the standard glass found on the iPhone 11 Pro Max. Both devices feature stainless steel frames, but the flat edges of the 12 Pro Max may provide a more secure grip for some users, potentially reducing the likelihood of accidental drops.
  • Repairability and Maintenance: Both models are well-supported by repair networks, with replacement parts like batteries and screens widely available. Because they share similar internal architectures, the ease of repair is comparable, though the 12 Pro Max's internal layout is slightly more modular in certain areas, which can simplify specific component replacements over time.

Year of Release

2019

2020

Compatible with latest Update

Yes

Yes

OS

iOS

iOS

Foldable

No

No

Performance

Performance differences between these two generations are most noticeable during intensive tasks such as high-resolution video editing or playing demanding mobile games.

  • System Responsiveness: The iPhone 12 Pro Max features an updated internal processor and increased memory compared to the 11 Pro Max. This extra memory allows the 12 Pro Max to keep more applications open in the background without needing to reload them, resulting in a smoother multitasking experience for power users who frequently switch between heavy apps.
  • Battery Efficiency: The iPhone 11 Pro Max is widely recognised for its exceptional battery life, often lasting through a full day of heavy use with ease. The iPhone 12 Pro Max offers similar real-world battery performance; however, its hardware is designed to be more efficient when handling complex tasks, which helps balance the power demands of its larger screen and newer connectivity features.
  • Storage and Data Handling: Both devices offer various storage capacities to suit different user needs, ranging from 64GB or 128GB up to 512GB. The 12 Pro Max starts with a higher base storage capacity, which is beneficial for users who store many high-resolution photos and videos locally rather than relying solely on cloud storage.

Memory

4 GB

6 GB

Screen quality

While both devices utilise high-quality OLED technology, the iPhone 12 Pro Max offers a slightly larger and more refined viewing experience.

  • Display Size and Immersion: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a 6.5-inch display, while the iPhone 12 Pro Max increases this to 6.7 inches. This extra screen real estate is achieved by reducing the borders around the display, providing a more immersive experience for watching videos or reading long documents without significantly increasing the overall footprint of the device.
  • Clarity and Brightness: Both screens offer deep blacks and vibrant colours typical of OLED technology, with high peak brightness levels that make them easily readable even in direct sunlight. The 12 Pro Max has a slightly higher pixel count to maintain sharpness across its larger surface area, ensuring that text and images remain crisp and detailed.
  • Visual Smoothness: Both models operate at a standard refresh rate, providing a consistent and reliable visual experience. The transition between apps and scrolling through social media feeds feels fluid on both devices, though the increased processing power of the 12 Pro Max can make the interface feel slightly more reactive during heavy system load.

Resolution

1242 x 2688

1284 x 2778

Screen type

Super Retina XDR OLED

Super Retina XDR OLED

Audiovisual

The camera systems on both devices are highly capable, but the iPhone 12 Pro Max introduces hardware enhancements that specifically benefit photography in challenging conditions.

  • Low-Light Performance: The iPhone 12 Pro Max features a larger main camera sensor that can capture more light, along with a specialised depth-sensing sensor (LiDAR). This allows for faster and more accurate focusing in dark environments and enables the use of Night Mode for portrait photography, a feature not available on the 11 Pro Max.
  • Video Recording Features: Both smartphones are excellent tools for video, capable of recording in 4K resolution. However, the 12 Pro Max adds the ability to record and edit video in a high-dynamic-range format (Dolby Vision), which provides more detail in the brightest and darkest parts of a scene, making it a preferred choice for mobile content creators.
  • Zoom and Versatility: Both models feature a triple-lens setup including Wide, Ultra Wide, and Telephoto lenses. The 12 Pro Max offers a slightly longer optical zoom range on its telephoto lens, allowing users to get closer to distant subjects without losing image quality compared to the 11 Pro Max.

Main camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond the core specifications, several practical design choices and connectivity standards distinguish these two generations of smartphones.

  • Network Connectivity: The most significant functional difference is that the iPhone 12 Pro Max supports 5G networks, whereas the iPhone 11 Pro Max is limited to 4G LTE. For users in areas with 5G coverage, the 12 Pro Max can offer significantly faster download and upload speeds, making it more future-ready as network infrastructure evolves.
  • Design and Ergonomics: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features rounded stainless steel edges that many users find comfortable for long periods of handheld use. In contrast, the iPhone 12 Pro Max adopts a flat-edge design that provides a more modern look and a different tactile feel. The 12 Pro Max is also slightly thinner but marginally heavier than its predecessor.
  • Charging and Accessories: The 12 Pro Max introduced a magnetic system on the back of the device (MagSafe), which allows for easy attachment of wireless chargers and other accessories like wallets or car mounts. The 11 Pro Max supports standard wireless charging but lacks the magnetic alignment and specialized accessory ecosystem of the newer model.

Weight

226 g

226 g

Screen size (in)

6.5

6.7

Network

4G

5G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

Connector

Lightning

Lightning

In summary, the choice between the iPhone 11 Pro Max and the iPhone 12 Pro Max often comes down to a preference for design and a requirement for modern connectivity. User consensus from various tech forums suggests that the iPhone 11 Pro Max remains a favourite for those who value its comfortable rounded design and its reputation for reliable, long-lasting battery life. It continues to be a powerful device for everyday tasks, photography, and media consumption. On the other hand, the iPhone 12 Pro Max is frequently praised for its updated aesthetic, the inclusion of 5G, and its superior performance in low-light photography thanks to the larger sensor and depth-sensing technology.

Users who prioritise having the latest network speeds and a more durable screen material will likely find the iPhone 12 Pro Max better suited to their needs. Conversely, users who prefer a more traditional handheld feel and do not require 5G connectivity may find the iPhone 11 Pro Max provides everything they need for a high-quality smartphone experience. Choosing a quality-assured refurbished option allows users to access these high-end features while supporting a more circular economy. Ultimately, both devices are highly capable tools that offer a premium experience, and opting for a sustainable choice through refurbishment ensures that these powerful devices continue to provide utility for years to come. Whether you value the refined classic design of the 11 Pro Max or the modern, feature-rich 12 Pro Max, both remain excellent examples of mobile engineering.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons