iPhone 12 Pro Max Vs iPhone XS

iPhone 12 Pro Max
iPhone 12 Pro Max
Starting at

Refurbished price:£238.00

Versus £979.00 new

See options
iPhone XS
iPhone XS
Starting at

Refurbished price:£102.00

Versus £399.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 12 Pro Max, released in November 2020, and the iPhone XS, launched in September 2018, represent different generations of Apple's premium smartphone offerings. While both devices operate on Apple's iOS ecosystem, the 12 Pro Max introduces a larger display, an enhanced camera system, and updated internal components compared to its predecessor. This comparison will delve into their practical differences to help users determine which device aligns best with their needs.

Scores

Durability

When considering the longevity of these devices, their respective release timelines and ongoing software support are key factors.

  • Release Timeline: The iPhone XS was released in September 2018, making it a significantly older model than the iPhone 12 Pro Max, which launched in November 2020. This age difference directly impacts their expected practical lifespan.
  • OS Support Duration: The iPhone 12 Pro Max, having been released more recently, is expected to receive software updates for a longer period than the iPhone XS. While the iPhone XS launched with iOS 12 and can be updated to iOS 18.x, it cannot support iOS 26 due to hardware limitations. The iPhone 12 Pro Max, starting with iOS 14.1, is compatible with later iOS versions, including iOS 26.2.1, offering extended software longevity.
  • Repairability: Both models present similar challenges regarding repairability due to Apple's use of proprietary components and software locks for certain parts. The iPhone 12 Pro Max received an iFixit repairability score of 6 out of 10, noting that while many parts are replaceable, specific components like cameras and screens may require Apple's proprietary system configuration for full functionality after replacement.

Year of Release

2020

2018

Compatible with latest Update

Yes

Yes

OS

iOS

iOS

Foldable

No

No

Performance

The performance of a smartphone is largely determined by its internal processing power and how efficiently it manages tasks and power consumption.

  • Processing Capabilities: The iPhone 12 Pro Max features a newer generation processor, which translates to noticeably faster app loading times, smoother multitasking, and more fluid performance in demanding applications and games. The iPhone XS, while still capable for everyday use, may exhibit slower responsiveness with newer, more intensive apps due to its older processor.
  • Battery Behavior: The iPhone 12 Pro Max is equipped with a larger 3687 mAh battery, offering extended usage times compared to the iPhone XS's 2658 mAh battery. Users of the 12 Pro Max can expect up to 14 hours of video playback or 12 hours of internet use, whereas the iPhone XS provides up to 14 hours of video playback or 12 hours of internet use, but with a smaller overall capacity. The 12 Pro Max also benefits from efficiency improvements in its newer processor, which helps conserve battery life, especially with features like 5G connectivity.
  • Storage Options: The iPhone 12 Pro Max offers more generous storage configurations, starting at 128GB and going up to 1TB, catering to users with extensive storage needs for photos, videos, and applications. The iPhone XS was available with 64GB, 256GB, or 512GB storage options.

Memory

6 GB

4 GB

Screen quality

The visual experience is a primary consideration for many smartphone users, and both devices offer high-quality displays with distinct characteristics.

  • Display Technology and Size: Both the iPhone 12 Pro Max and iPhone XS feature OLED Super Retina displays, known for their deep blacks and vibrant colors. However, the iPhone 12 Pro Max boasts a significantly larger 6.7-inch display, providing a more expansive viewing area compared to the iPhone XS's 5.8-inch screen.
  • Resolution and Clarity: While both phones offer excellent pixel density (458 ppi), the iPhone 12 Pro Max has a higher overall resolution of 2778x1284 pixels, contributing to a sharper image on its larger screen. The iPhone XS has a resolution of 2436 x 1125 pixels.
  • Brightness Levels: The iPhone 12 Pro Max offers superior brightness, reaching up to 800 nits typical maximum brightness and 1200 nits for HDR content, which enhances visibility in bright outdoor conditions and improves the dynamic range of HDR videos. The iPhone XS has a lower peak brightness.

Resolution

1284 x 2778

1125 x 2436

Screen type

Super Retina XDR OLED

Super Retina OLED

Audiovisual

For photography and videography enthusiasts, the camera systems are often a deciding factor, and there are notable advancements between these two models.

  • Rear Camera System: The iPhone 12 Pro Max features a more advanced triple 12MP camera system, including Ultra Wide, Wide, and Telephoto lenses, with a wider f/1.6 aperture on its main wide camera for improved low-light performance. It also incorporates sensor-shift optical image stabilization on the wide camera, enhancing stability for both photos and videos. The iPhone XS has a dual 12MP camera system with wide (f/1.8) and telephoto (f/2.4) lenses, offering 2x optical zoom.
  • Computational Photography and Features: The 12 Pro Max benefits from features like Night mode, Deep Fusion, Smart HDR 3, and a LiDAR Scanner, which aids in faster autofocus in low light and enables Night mode portraits. It also supports Apple ProRAW for more editing flexibility and HDR video recording with Dolby Vision up to 60 fps. The iPhone XS introduced Smart HDR and Portrait mode with Depth Control but lacks Night mode and the advanced video capabilities of the 12 Pro Max.
  • Front Camera: The iPhone 12 Pro Max has a 12MP front camera with Night mode and Deep Fusion, capable of 4K video recording up to 60fps. The iPhone XS features a 7MP front camera that records 1080p HD video.

Main camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

7 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and display, several practical features contribute to the overall user experience.

  • Connectivity: A significant difference is the iPhone 12 Pro Max's support for 5G connectivity, offering faster download and upload speeds in compatible areas, alongside Wi-Fi 6 for improved wireless performance. The iPhone XS supports Gigabit LTE and Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac). Both devices include Bluetooth 5.0 and NFC.
  • Physical Design and Durability: The iPhone 12 Pro Max features a flat-edge stainless steel design and a Ceramic Shield front cover, which Apple states offers enhanced drop performance. Both models have an IP68 rating for water and dust resistance, though the 12 Pro Max is rated for submersion up to 6 meters for 30 minutes, while the XS is rated for 2 meters for 30 minutes. The 12 Pro Max is also larger and heavier, measuring 160.8 x 78.1 x 7.4 mm and weighing 228 grams, compared to the iPhone XS's 143.6 x 70.9 x 7.7 mm and 177 grams.
  • Additional Features: The iPhone 12 Pro Max introduces MagSafe, a magnetic system for wireless charging and accessories. Both devices rely on Face ID for biometric authentication and use the Lightning port for charging and data transfer.

Weight

226 g

177 g

Screen size (in)

6.7

5.8

Network

5G

4G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

Connector

Lightning

Lightning

The iPhone 12 Pro Max and iPhone XS cater to different user priorities, largely due to the generational advancements in technology. Users often praise the iPhone 12 Pro Max for its expansive display, significantly improved camera capabilities, especially in low light, and its robust performance for demanding tasks and future-proofing with 5G connectivity. Common feedback highlights its excellent battery life and the benefits of the MagSafe ecosystem. Some users, however, find its larger size and weight less convenient for one-handed use.

The iPhone XS, on the other hand, is frequently lauded for its more compact form factor, which many find comfortable to handle. Its OLED display still offers a vibrant viewing experience, and its performance remains adequate for general daily use and less intensive applications. Criticisms often revolve around its comparatively shorter battery life and the absence of features like Night mode in its camera system, which has become a standard expectation in newer models. Its software support window is also nearing its end compared to the 12 Pro Max.

Users prioritizing a large, immersive display, cutting-edge camera technology for both photos and videos, and the fastest available performance for gaming and productivity will find the iPhone 12 Pro Max well-suited to their needs. Its longer software support and 5G capabilities also make it a more future-ready option. Conversely, users who prefer a more compact device, primarily use their phone for everyday tasks, and are less concerned with the absolute latest camera innovations may lean towards the iPhone XS. Both devices, especially when considering quality-assured refurbished options, offer a sustainable choice for consumers looking to extend the life cycle of electronic products.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons