iPhone 11 Pro Max Vs iPhone XS

iPhone 11 Pro Max
iPhone 11 Pro Max
Starting at

Refurbished price:£180.00

Versus £749.00 new

See options
iPhone XS
iPhone XS
Starting at

Refurbished price:£93.00

Versus £399.00 new

See options

Ratings

The iPhone 11 Pro Max, released in September 2019, and the iPhone Xs, launched in September 2018, represent two generations of Apple's premium smartphone offerings. While both devices share a similar design philosophy and operate on Apple's iOS ecosystem, the 11 Pro Max introduced notable advancements in camera technology, processing power, and battery longevity. These differences cater to varying user priorities, from photography enthusiasts to those seeking extended device usage between charges.

Scores

Durability

When considering the long-term usability of these devices, their release timelines and subsequent software support are key factors.

  • Release Timeline and OS Support: The iPhone Xs, released in 2018, shipped with iOS 12 and is capable of running up to iOS 17. The iPhone 11 Pro Max, from 2019, launched with iOS 13 and is expected to receive software updates for at least one year longer than the Xs, potentially supporting future iOS versions beyond iOS 17. This extended support means the 11 Pro Max will benefit from newer features and security updates for a longer period.
  • Repairability and Practical Lifespan: Both models feature glass front and back panels, making them susceptible to damage from drops. Repairability scores are generally moderate for iPhones of these generations, with common repairs like screen and battery replacements being feasible. The practical lifespan for both devices, assuming proper care, can extend several years beyond their last major OS update, especially when considering quality-assured refurbished options.
  • Durability Features: The iPhone 11 Pro Max offers an improved IP68 water and dust resistance rating, capable of withstanding submersion up to 4 meters for 30 minutes, compared to the iPhone Xs's IP68 rating of up to 2 meters for 30 minutes. This provides a slight edge in protection against accidental liquid exposure for the newer model.

Year of Release

2019

2018

Compatible with latest Update

Yes

Yes

OS

iOS

iOS

Foldable

No

No

Performance

Performance is a critical aspect for daily smartphone use, influencing everything from app responsiveness to demanding tasks like gaming and video editing.

  • Processing Capabilities: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a newer generation processor, which provides a noticeable boost in overall speed and efficiency compared to the iPhone Xs's processor. This translates to faster app loading times, smoother multitasking, and more fluid performance in graphically intensive games and applications.
  • Multitasking and Responsiveness: Both devices come with 4GB of RAM, allowing for competent multitasking. However, the 11 Pro Max's more advanced processor architecture means it handles background processes and transitions between apps with greater ease, maintaining responsiveness even under heavier loads.
  • Battery Behavior: The iPhone 11 Pro Max delivers significantly improved battery life, often lasting a full day or even two days for moderate users, and consistently outperforming the iPhone Xs by several hours in various usage tests. The iPhone Xs provides a solid day of use for many, but heavy users may find themselves seeking a charger sooner. The 11 Pro Max also supports faster wired charging with an included 18W adapter, reaching 50% charge in about 30 minutes.

Memory (GB)

4 GB

4 GB

Screen quality

Both the iPhone 11 Pro Max and iPhone Xs offer high-quality OLED displays, providing vibrant visuals and deep blacks, though with some distinctions.

  • Display Technology and Clarity: Both models feature Super Retina OLED displays, delivering excellent contrast and color accuracy. The iPhone 11 Pro Max boasts a Super Retina XDR display, while the iPhone Xs has a Super Retina HD display. Both have a pixel density of 458 pixels per inch (ppi), ensuring sharp text and detailed images.
  • Brightness Levels: The iPhone 11 Pro Max offers a higher typical maximum brightness of 800 nits, with a peak HDR brightness of 1200 nits, making it more visible in bright outdoor conditions and enhancing HDR content. The iPhone Xs has a typical maximum brightness of 625 nits.
  • Screen Size and Features: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a larger 6.5-inch display, providing a more expansive viewing experience compared to the iPhone Xs's 5.8-inch screen. The iPhone Xs includes 3D Touch for pressure-sensitive interactions, a feature replaced by Haptic Touch on the 11 Pro Max. Both displays support True Tone and wide color (P3) for accurate color representation.

Resolution

1242 x 2688

1125 x 2436

Screen type

Super Retina XDR OLED

Super Retina OLED

Audiovisual

The camera systems are a significant point of divergence, with the iPhone 11 Pro Max introducing a more versatile setup.

  • Rear Camera System: The iPhone 11 Pro Max features a triple 12MP camera system, including Ultra Wide, Wide, and Telephoto lenses, offering greater photographic flexibility. The iPhone Xs has a dual 12MP camera system with Wide and Telephoto lenses. The 11 Pro Max's Ultra Wide lens allows for capturing broader scenes, while its Wide and Telephoto lenses benefit from a larger sensor and improved aperture for better light gathering.
  • Photography Features: A key advantage of the 11 Pro Max is the inclusion of Night mode, which significantly improves low-light photography, and Deep Fusion, which enhances detail and texture in medium-light conditions. Both models offer Smart HDR and Portrait mode with Depth Control, but the 11 Pro Max's implementation is more advanced, producing more refined results.
  • Front Camera and Video Quality: The iPhone 11 Pro Max upgrades the front-facing camera to 12MP, capable of recording 4K video and slow-motion selfies. The iPhone Xs has a 7MP front camera that records 1080p HD video. Both devices record 4K video at up to 60 frames per second with optical image stabilization, but the 11 Pro Max offers extended dynamic range for video up to 60fps, compared to 30fps on the Xs.

Main camera

12 megapixels

12 megapixels

Front camera

12 megapixels

7 megapixels

Miscellaneous

Beyond core performance and camera, several practical elements contribute to the overall user experience of these smartphones.

  • Connectivity and Ports: The iPhone 11 Pro Max supports Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax), offering faster and more efficient wireless connections compared to the iPhone Xs's Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac). Both devices feature Bluetooth 5.0 and Gigabit-class LTE for cellular connectivity. Both utilize a Lightning port for charging and data transfer, and neither includes a traditional 3.5mm headphone jack.
  • Sensors and Biometrics: Both models rely on Face ID for secure facial recognition. The iPhone 11 Pro Max introduced the U1 Ultra Wideband chip, which enhances spatial awareness and improves features like AirDrop. Other standard sensors like accelerometers, gyroscopes, and barometers are present in both.
  • Physical Design and Handling: The iPhone 11 Pro Max is slightly larger and heavier than the iPhone Xs, measuring 158.0 x 77.8 x 8.1 mm and weighing 226 grams, compared to the Xs's 143.6 x 70.9 x 7.7 mm and 177 grams. This difference in size and weight can impact one-handed use and pocketability. Both feature a glass and stainless steel construction, contributing to a premium feel.

Weight

226 g

177 g

Screen size (in)

6.5

5.8

Mobile network

4G

4G

SIM card

Physical SIM + eSIM

Physical SIM + eSIM

Carrier compatibility

Unlocked

Unlocked

Connector

Lightning

Lightning

User feedback for both the iPhone 11 Pro Max and iPhone Xs generally highlights their strengths and areas for consideration. The iPhone Xs is often praised for its compact size, still-capable performance for everyday tasks, and vibrant OLED display. Users appreciate its solid build quality and the introduction of Face ID. However, common criticisms include its battery life, which some heavy users found insufficient for a full day, and the absence of a dedicated Night mode for photography.

The iPhone 11 Pro Max, on the other hand, receives significant acclaim for its substantially improved battery life, often cited as a major upgrade that allows for extended usage without frequent recharging. Its triple-camera system, particularly the addition of the Ultra Wide lens and Night mode, is frequently lauded for enhancing photographic versatility and quality, especially in challenging lighting conditions. Some users, however, find its larger size and weight less comfortable for one-handed operation.

Users prioritizing a more compact device with capable performance for general use and who do not require the absolute latest camera features or extended battery life may find the iPhone Xs suitable. Conversely, those who value a larger display, significantly longer battery life, and a more advanced and versatile camera system, particularly for low-light photography and wide-angle shots, will likely prefer the iPhone 11 Pro Max. Both models remain viable options, especially when considering them as quality-assured refurbished alternatives, offering a sustainable choice for consumers.

See all articles

Our recent comparisons